INT.FREDDY’S APARTMENT – BREAKFAST – A DAY OR SO AFTER 9-11
Freddy and his dad are sitting at a small table. His dad is drinking coffee, smoking, and reading the paper.
FREDDY’S DAD
Can you believe it? Fucking Arabs brought down those buildings?! You got any Arabs
at school because if you do I think they’ll need to be home schooled.
FREDDY
(Amused.)
No, Dad, we don’t got any Arabs. But now that they blew up those buildings they’ll
probably start going to Jefferson.
FREDDY’S DAD
(Looking over his paper.)
I know that’s a joke but I don’t get it.
FREDDY
(Smiling.)
Cause you gotta be a criminal to get into Jefferson.
FREDDY’S DAD
(Interested.)
Not true. You’re not a criminal.
FREDDY
(Big smile.)
Not yet, but who knows? You know what they say about Jefferson High?
FREDDY’S DAD
No, what do they say?
FREDDY
That at Jefferson most the students major in criminology.
FREDDY’S DAD
(Smiling but concerned.)
Okay, funnyman, ha, ha. But you’re not serious, are you?
FREDDY
A little. I mean we just had an assembly on school violence. Did you know a teacher
was stabbed two years ago a Jefferson?
FREDDY’S DAD
No I didn’t. They didn’t say anything about a teacher being stabbed when I enrolled
you.
FREDDY
What do you expect, Dad? Ain’t all that many white kids at the school as is. Wouldn’t
be any if they told the parents what goes on at the school. I wouldn’t mind having a
few Arabs at school. The bangers would kick their asses instead of hasslin me.
FREDDY’S DAD
(Smiling.)
This will be the last year. I promise. I’m going to get a better job soon and we’ll get
out of this neighborhood.
FREDDY
You know I wouldn’t even mind goin back to Iowa.
FREDDY’S DAD
That’s an option too. Just need to learn a little more on this job and save some money.
So tell me, has the school talked about the attacks?
FREDDY
Yeah, and today we’re gonna talk some more about them in social studies, you know
to show the government’s concerned about our safety.
FREDDY’S DAD
(Bitter.)
The government looks out for itself. I’m just glad I’m out of the army. You know 9/11
wouldn’t have happened if our government hadn’t been interfering in other peoples’
territories in the first place.
FREDDY
Sounds like the government could learn somethin about territory from the bangers.
They’ll tell you if you want to get into trouble be messin around in their territory.
FREDDY’S DAD
That’s true. Hussein should have learned that lesson when he invaded Iran. But he
didn’t and invaded Kuwait. Of course, if Kuwait exported turnips instead of oil the
country would now belong to Hussein. We’ll just have to wait and see if Bush is
smarter than Hussein, but I have my doubts. (Look of concern.) But I do know one
thing and that’s the future doesn’t look all that good.
FREDDY
(Interested.)
You were in the Army, Dad. Do you think those Arabs can kick our ass?
FREDDY’S DAD
No, no way they can do that. But with a loser as a president we might end up defeating
ourselves. To show you how stupid our government can be, it actually supported
Hussein during the Iraq-Iran war, though he started the war. The Iraqis even attacked
an American warship, the U.S.S. Stark killing a bunch of American sailors. The
government has its own agenda and it has very little to do with the welfare of
Americans and a lot to do with special interest groups like big oil and Israel.
(Looking at the clock.) Shouldn’t you be getting off to school?
FREDDY
(Glumly.)
Yeah, I guess so. (More upbeat.) We had a pretty good conversation, didn’t we,
Dad?
FREDDY’S DAD
(Smiling.)
Yeah we did. I’ll see you tonight.
FREDDY
Maybe we can watch some TV.
FREDDY’S DAD
Sure thing—after you’ve done your homework.
FREDDY
(Hopeful, yet uncertain expression.)
Okay.
Freddy grabs his pack, opens, the door...
FREDDY
Bye, Dad.
FREDDY’S DAD
(Watching Freddy leave.)
Bye, son. Have a great day at school.
INT. MS WHINER’S SOCIAL STUDIES CLASS
Ms. Whiner (young, open-minded and Jewish) stands at the front of the class. She is dress in black, almost as if in mourning. She looks beautiful.
MS WHINER
So class, after the attacks what you think about the government. Is it doing
everything possible to protect us? Does it have everything under control?
JARRELL JOHNSON
(Contemptuously.)
What are you sayin? From the way I see things, the government don’t got nothin
under control. I mean if the government was doin its job those buildings would still be
standing. The problem is the government is always looking out for itself and its fat-cat
friends. Niggers have known that for a long time. What folks like you are just
beginning to find that out.
MS WHINER
Jarrell, I wish you wouldn’t use that word in class.
JARRELL
You mean nigger?
MS WHINER
Yes.
JARRELL
Whatever.
MS WHINER
(To the class.)
Getting back to the topic. I agree with Jarrell that the government is imperfect, but I
think it’s doing everything it can to protect us...
JARRELL
(Interrupting.)
You’re sounding like you work for the government.
MS WHINER
No, Jarrell, I don’t work for the government. What I am saying is...
A STUDENT
(Interrupting.)
Sure you do. Jefferson ain’t no private school like the fancy pants school across the
street. You're a government worker.
MS WHINER
(Trying to be patient.)
That’s true, but I don’t work for the federal government. But my point is that it’s an
imperfect world and...
JARRELL
(Interrupting.)
You live around here, Ms Whiner?
MS WHINER
(Frustrated at being interrupted again.)
No I don’t.
JARRELL
Well if you did, you’d know you don’t need to be tellin us about how imperfect the
world is. We know all about that. Little ol Freddy can tell you about livin in an
imperfect world, can’t you, Freddy, ‘cause first day of class he got his white ass run
over by one of his own, didn’t you, Freddy?
Ms Whiner looks over at Freddy, who scoots down in his seat embarrassed.
JARRELL
No, Ms Whiner you don’t need to be tellin us about how imperfect the world is. We
already know that and we also know the cops can’t protect us, like they didn’t protect
Tyrone, and the FBI can’t protect us, like they didn’t protect those people on the planes
or in those buildings they crashed into. Besides, we ain’t worried about no Arabs cause
most likely if we get killed it will be some negga or beaner or honky doin the
killin. Fuck.
MS WHINER
(Frustrated but sympathetic.)
Jarrell, I would really appreciate it if you would watch your language while in class.
JARRELL
Sorry, Ms Whiner. I’ll try to watch it but I can’t make no promises ‘cause the way I
talk is normal talk outside.
MS WHINER
I understand. (Turning to the whole class.) So tell me class, since the attacks do you
think Americans have a better understanding of what Israelis have to face every day?
HENRY: A NERDY JEWISH STUDENT
(Raises his hand.)
Ms Whiner I thought we’re supposed to be discussing the Arabs attacking America not
talking about Israel.
MS WHINER
That is correct, Henry, I just thought it would be interesting to compare our experience
with a nation that has suffered these types of attacks repeatedly for decades.
HENRY
Well we know why the Arabs don’t like the Jews in Israel. It’s because they took land
belonging to the Palestinians...
JARRELL
(Jumping in.)
That’s the territory thing. You see Ms Whiner you come into my neighborhood and try
to take over, you’re goin to be swimmin in deep shit...
MS WHINER
(Interrupting.)
Jarrell, I thought we had an agreement about that kind of language...
JARRELL
(Interrupting.)
We do Ms Whiner, and I’m goin to work on it, but I’ve been on the streets all summer
talkin dirty. So I need some time, but we got an agreement.
MS WHINER
Okay, okay, Jarrell, I’m glad we still have our agreement. You were saying something
about territory. Please finish your thought.
JARRELL
What I was sayin is that each neighborhood’s got a gang to protect it from intruders.
Blacks, Mexicans, Asians—all got local gangs that watch out for their territory, and if
you come messin around like taggin and shit, you’re gonna get hurt bad.
MS WHINER
But, Jarrell, where I live we have no gangs...
JARRELL
(Interrupting.)
Yeah you do—the cops, and if me and some of my hommies decided to take a drive
through your neighborhood they’d be all over us. And if we messed with them, like
just talkin back, we’d end of dead or our heads beat in. Every place’s got a gang
watchin its territory. You better believe it.
HENRY
(Raising his hand.)
MS WHINER
Yes, Henry.
HENRY
Did you know, Ms Whiner, that the first black gangs in L.A. were formed to protect
black people from whites?
MS WHINER
No, I didn’t know that, Henry. That’s very interesting.
JARRELL
And that’s why the Arabs are always blowin themselves up someplace where there’s
lot of Jews, ‘cause the Jews squatted on their territory.
MS WHINER
But after the Holocaust the Jewish people needed somewhere to go to be safe.
JARRELL
I thought two wrongs don’t make a right. They should of moved to Nevada. Lots of
empty desert just like Israel and they could of built a Jerusalem casino and got rich off
all the American Christians. And they’d be a lot safer than where they are. I mean my
neighborhood is dangerous but at least the bangers aren’t blowin themselves up
on buses. They ain’t that stupid.
HENRY
(Raising his hand excitedly but not waiting to be called upon.)
And did you know that before the Jews moved in, Palestine was under the control of
the British, who helped create the state of Israel with the help of America and the
Soviets? And America has been arming Israel ever since. That’s the reason the Arabs
hate us. So yeah, now we know how the Israelis feel and it happened to us for the same
reason that Jarrell was talking about, messing around in Arab territory.
Freddy raises his hand. Ms Whiner has become uncomfortable with the tone and direction of the discussion, so is a little nervous about what Freddy might say.
MS WHINER
Yes Freddy?
FREDDY
(Shyly.)
If Henry’s right, then them 9/11 attacks were bad karma.
MS WHINER
How’s that, Freddy?
FREDDY
Karma means that doing something bad can have a bad effect later on, or doin
somethin good can have a good effect, like maybe America’s been acting like a bully
over in Arab territory, pushin em around tellin em what to do, like accepting the
Jews taken over, and so they just got tired of it and decided to kill some of the bully’s
people. And I don’t blame them.
MS WHINER
(Concerned.)
Why’s that, Freddy?
Music becomes ominous, like the soundtrack of The Human Stain.
JARRELL
(Jumping in.)
I’ll tell you why. It’s ‘cause Freddy knows all about being bullied, don’t you, Freddy?
Spike and his pathetic crew always fuckin with you ‘cause they know better than to
mess around with the neggas or them loco Mexicans. Ain’t that right, Freddy?
MS WHINER
Jarrell, don’t say anything else because if you do and it has words that you know are
forbidden in class, I will send to you Mr. Hurt and get you detention.
JARRELL
(Contemptuously.)
Whatever, but Freddy knows I’m right. It’s the way the world works, big fish eats little
fish, and little fish eats shit.
MS WHINER
That’s it, Jarrell. You got detention. Do you want suspension?
JARRELL
(Smiling wryly.)
You mean a couple of days off from Jefferson? Anytime. But don’t make promises you
can’t keep.
MS WHINER
(Beginning to lose control of herself.)
Well, maybe I need to speak to your parents.
JARRELL
You mean my mom ‘cause you’ll need a visitor’s pass to talk to my daddy? You see
Ms. Whiner, what you do don’t matter none. And I ain’t angry or nothing. You gotta
do your job. I know that. But it don’t matter none. That’s all I’m saying.
HENRY
(Again raising his hand excitedly.)
MS WHINER
(Wearily.)
Yes, Henry.
HENRY
I just want to put what Jarrell and Freddy said together to get back to what you said
about Americans now knowing what it’s like to be Jews in Israel.
MS WHINER
Okay, Henry, why don’t you make the connection and we’ll call it a day because the
class is almost over.
HENRY
Well, the way I see it, when the Jews invaded Palestine and created Israel on
Palestinian territory they could expect trouble from the Arabs for the reason Jarrell
explained. They’re going to hate the Jews and fight them forever for taking their
territory. But like what Freddy said, the creation of Israel on the lands of the
Palestinians also created bad karma, mostly wars and bombings that keep happening.
And because America supported the Jews against the Palestinians the Jewish bad
karma finally caught up with Americans on September 11.
MS WHINER
Very good, Henry. I think we had a very good discussion today, led by Henry, Jarrell,
and Freddy. Though I still need to see you after class, Jarrell.
The students file out of class. Jarrell hangs back. Ms Whiner waits, and he finally walks over to her.
JARRELL
(Sullen.)
I don’t think it right you jumpin on me for somethin I can’t help.
MS WHINER
(Sympathetically.)
I know, Jarrell, but I can’t just let that kind of talk go on in class; otherwise, all the
students will be talking trash. But that’s not what I want to talk with you about.
JARRELL
(Surprised.)
That’s good, but I don’t get it.
FREDDY
It’s what you said about Freddy. Is he being bullied on campus?
JARRELL
Big time. I mean he ain’t the only one you know. But Spike and his posse has got it out for him. Don’t ask me why. They’re a bunch of losers themselves, and don’t go saying I told you anything, ‘cause I’ll deny it.
MS WHINER
(Concerned.)
But why Freddy? He hasn’t done anything.
JARRELL
You just don’t get it, Ms Whiner. He’s weak and don’t have a crew.
MS WHINER
I don’t understand, Jarrell.
JARRELL
Backup. He ain’t got any backup. I mean he’s got a couple friends but losers just like
him. Only that crazy Jackie whatshisname...
MS WHINER
Jackie Neihiler.
JARRELL
That’s it, like what kind of name is that? Anyway he’s the only one you’d worry about
because he’s nuts, as far as I can see, always wearin that trench coat like he goin to
do a Columbine. But they’re losers. Ain’t nothin to be afraid of. If Spike messed with
me I’d hammer him, even if he is older than me. Skinny punk ass...
MS WHINER
Jarrell, please...
JARRELL
Sorry, Ms Whiner. What I’m sayin is just that if you don’t got backup you can expect
to be bullied. And Freddy's got no backup.
MS WHINER
(Appealing.)
What about you?
JARRELL
What about me? What?
MS WHINER
Couldn’t you kind of look out for him?
JARRELL
What? Haven’t you noticed that he’s white and I’m black? White and black
don’t mix.
MS WHINER
That’s too bad.
JARRELL
Maybe so, but that’s just how it is. Can I go now?
MS WHINER
Sure. Thanks for the information.
JARRELL
Hey, I didn’t tell you nothin’.
MS WHINER
I understand.
Jarrell smiles and walks off. Last shot of Ms. Whiner looking pensive, sad.